Table of Contents
The Decline of Middle-earth in Gaming
Once a powerhouse in video games, The Lord of the Rings franchise delivered some of the most memorable titles in the early 2000s. Games like The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers and The Return of the King, released alongside Peter Jackson's films, captured the epic scale of J.R.R. Tolkien's world with tight action and faithful storytelling. These tie-ins set a high bar, blending cinematic moments with solid gameplay that thrilled fans on platforms from Game Boy Advance to PlayStation 2.
Later entries like Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor (2014) and its sequel Shadow of War (2017) elevated the series further. Developed by Monolith Productions, they introduced the innovative Nemesis System, where enemy orcs remembered player encounters, creating dynamic rivalries and alliances. These open-world action games earned critical acclaim for their combat, exploration, and deep lore integration, proving Middle-earth could thrive in modern AAA gaming.
Recent Disappointments and Studio Fallout
The momentum stalled in recent years. The Lord of the Rings: Gollum, released in May 2023 by Daedalic Entertainment, promised a stealth-focused adventure through the eyes of the iconic creature. Instead, it faced severe backlash for buggy performance, lackluster graphics, and repetitive gameplay. The troubled launch was so damaging that Daedalic canceled its sequel and exited game development entirely.
2024's Tales of the Shire: A The Lord of the Rings Game, a cozy life sim from Private Division and Weta Workshop, arrived with mixed reviews. Set for Nintendo Switch eShop on July 29, 2025, in some regions, it shifted focus to hobbit cooking and village-building but failed to recapture the adventure fans craved.
Other attempts, like The Lord of the Rings: Return to Moria, a survival crafting game in the Fourth Age, have garnered niche appeal on Steam. Updates like Title Update 6 and the Durin's Folk Expansion add quality-of-life fixes and new content, but it hasn't achieved mainstream success.
A Promising AAA Horizon Emerges
Hope is rising with reports of a new third-person action game in development, designed to compete directly with Hogwarts Legacy. Insider Gaming sources reveal the untitled project, backed by approximately $100 million USD from the Abu Dhabi Investment Office (ADIO), emphasizes massive scale and single-player depth. A public deal announcement could come as early as next week.
Embracer Group, which holds significant Lord of the Rings rights, has been prototyping multiple titles. Their head of LOTR gaming, Lee Guinchard, previously called for a 'renaissance' in Middle-earth games. This new effort aligns with that vision, potentially featuring open-world RPG elements, custom characters, and expansive storytelling.
Additionally, Embracer partners with Amazon Games on an unannounced MMO set in Middle-earth, expanding the franchise's multiplayer potential.
Key Lord of the Rings Games: Hits and Misses
- Peaks: Shadow of Mordor/War (Nemesis System innovation), early movie tie-ins like Return of the King.
- Flops: Gollum (2023, led to studio closure), Tales of the Shire (mixed reception).
- Upcoming: New AAA action game ($100M budget), Amazon MMO, Return to Moria expansions.
What Fans Want Next
The franchise's future hinges on recapturing the epic feel of its best entries. Fans yearn for high-fidelity graphics, meaningful player choice, and lore-respecting narratives. With substantial funding and competitive ambitions, this new project could end the drought. As Embracer and partners invest heavily, Middle-earth gaming may return to its former glory, delivering the blockbuster experience long overdue.